Misconceptions about Buddhism

From Dhamma Wiki
Revision as of 18:02, 7 March 2024 by TheDhamma (talk | contribs)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Some of the many Misconceptions about Buddhism:


1. The Buddha is the fat guy.

Main article: Hotei

The statue of a bald, fat Buddha is actually a Chinese monk who lived in the 9th century CE.

2. All Buddhists are bald.

Main article: Hair

Although the shaving of the head is sometimes fashionable, such as the basketball players in the 1990's, the shaved head is one sign of being a monk or a nun in the Buddhist tradition, where it is considered to be one less thing to identify with or be attached to. Lay people rarely shave their heads and primarily do so for the same reasons non-Buddhists do so; for ease, comfort, or fashion.

3. All Buddhists are vegetarians.

Many Buddhists choose a vegetarian diet to better practice the First Precept, but not all. About half of all Buddhists are vegetarian or vegan and the other half regularly consumes meat, limits it somewhat, or eats meat only if served or offered it by others.

4. All Buddhists meditate.

Main article: Meditation

Meditation has been identified as the central practice of Buddhism (Edward Conze said that meditation is for Buddhism what prayer is for Christianity). It is unclear how many Christians actually pray, but the majority of Buddhists throughout history have not meditated. Meditation has, until rather recently, been considered a monastic practice, and even then, as a practice reserved for only certain monks. The Buddha did place great emphasis on meditation, but some traditions such as the Pure Land do little to no meditation in their practice.

5. All Buddhists who meditate sit in full lotus.

Main article: Meditation postures

Very few Buddhists sit in full-lotus when they meditate. The Buddha advocated for mindfulness at all times and not just when sitting or in a certain posture. All postures are acceptable and used.

6. Reincarnation is fun.

Main article: Rebirth

As much as anyone might like to come back to play centerfield for the Yankees, this is just not the way it works. If you are tired of people saying "Been there. Done that," just remember that Buddhists have been saying it in so many words for a couple of millennia. There is no place you have not been reborn, no form of sentient life that you have not already been a zillion times. It all should be a tedious bore right now, and all you should want to do is get out. Unless, of course, you're a bodhisattva.

7. All roads lead to the same mountaintop.

Main article: Heaven

Many great Buddhist figures, from Dogen to the current Dalai Lama, are emphatic on the point that enlightenment is only possible by following the Buddhist path. You can only get so far following other religions: all roads lead to Everest base camp, but from there, Buddhism is the only route to the summit. Buddhism holds that anyone can get to heaven leading a moral life and precepts from any religion, but the ultimate Nibbana is through the Buddhist path.

8. All Buddhists live in monasteries.

Main article: Upasaka and Upasika

Most Buddhists throughout history have been laypeople and hence have not lived in monasteries. They could not do so, because without the laity the monasteries could not survive.

9. You must be a monk or nun to get enlightened.

Main article: Lay arahant
Main article: Upasaka and Upasika

There are reports of lay people from all traditions who have attained enlightenment.

10. All Buddhists are hippies.

Main article: Precepts

Hardly, many Theravadins are quite conservative, as are some Zennies and Vajrayana Buddhists. Some follow what might be called rigid precepts and do not even drink alcohol.

11. Buddhists are idol worshipers.

Main article: Idolatry

Not true, some traditions don't even use statues much. And those that do, do not worship them, just pay respects to the teacher and teachings. There is a Zen saying that if it is cold and your statue is made of wood, throw the Buddha statue in the fire to keep warm.

12. The Dalai Lama is the head of Buddhism.

Main article: Dalai Lama

The Dalai Lama is the spiritual leader of the four major schools of Tibetan Buddhism, but not of the many other Mahayana schools, Zen schools, or Theravada.

13. Buddhists believe in reincarnation.

Main article: Anatta

It is actually rebirth, not a transmigrating soul.

14. Buddhists believe in karma which means they have no compassion because any handicap or other disability is the person's bad karma and their fault.

Main article: Kamma
Main article: Karuna

It is a common misconception that karma (Pali: Kamma) is the cause of everything. In actual fact Buddhism recognized at least four other broad causes of why things happen including natural laws (dhamma niyàma), biological laws (bãja niyàma), physical laws (utu niyàma) and psychological laws (citta niyàma). Some things happen due to weather, some by chance happenings and in all cases Buddhists are supposed to be compassionate. And one is not supposed to speculate about the workings of karma since one cannot know for sure if some negative outcome is the result of karma or if it is due to weather abnormalities or other causes.

Buddhists wear fashionable clothes just as much as non-Buddhists

15. Buddhists must wear robes.

Main article: Clothes & fashion
Main article: Buddhist fashion

Buddhists wear whatever they like and are not required to wear robes. Some Zen sects wear a robe, but that is only for the meditation session and it is immediately taken off before leaving the zendo. It is also worn over the regular clothes. Other schools of Buddhism, such as Vajrayana and Theravada do not wear any robes even during meditation and retreats (except for monastics of course).

16. The Buddha is God or one of the gods.

Main article: Buddha
Main article: Was the Buddha a God?

The Buddha was as mortal as any of us and got sick and died too. He attained enlightenment and Nibbana but was born a human in 563 BC in his final life. He was not a Son of God either, as found in Greek mythologies.

In the Anguttara Nikâya (I, 22), there is a clear instance in which the Buddha categorically declared that he was a human being:

"Monks, there is one person (puggala) whose birth into this world is for the welfare and happiness of many, out of compassion for the world, for the gain and welfare and happiness of gods (devas) and humanity. Who is this one person (eka puggala)? It is the Tathâgata, who is a Consummate One (arahat), a Supremely Enlightened One (sammâ-sambuddho)....Monks, one person born into the world is an extraordinary man, a marvellous man (acchariya manussa)."

17. Buddhism is a pessimistic religion.

Main article: The Four Noble Truths

The first noble truth is the noble truth of suffering. But there are 4 Noble Truths, not one. The rest deal with us getting out of suffering.

18. It's all an illusion.

Main article: 2 truths

Nothing can bare ultimate examination. It is not all an illusion, as if nothing is there. It is all like an illusion, as in being dependently arisen; dependently arisen is not something that is obvious to the ignorant mind.

The following extract from - Do objects Exist ? by the Dalai Lama : "Analysis does not contradict the mere existence of the object. Phenomena do indeed exist, but not in the way we think they do."

19. Buddhism is a reformation of Hinduism.

Main article: Hinduism

Buddhism is in sharp contrast to Hinduism. The Hinduism at the time of Buddha was Brahmanism and included a transmigrating soul, the caste system, polytheism, and animal sacrifices. The Buddha's teachings rejected a permanent soul, the caste system, and animal sacrifices. Buddhism is often referred to as a non-theistic religion.

Buddhists use or don't use cosmetics at the same rate as anyone else in the community / nation

20. Buddhists are all dreadfully serious people, don't wear make up and never have any fun.

Main article: Cosmetics
Main article: Smiling and laughter

Buddhists wear cosmetics, if they so choose, but do not use them during retreats and other days when they want to focus on their meditation practice. At other times, Buddhists use or don't use cosmetics at the same rate as anyone else in the community / nation. Buddhists strive for equanimity, which is a balanced state of mind, primarily so that they do not react to situations especially with anger or without thought. Buddhists still can know how to have a good time, but attempt to do so without attachment. Ajahn Brahm and the Dalai Lama as well as many other famous teachers are known for their great sense of humor and frequently tell jokes, laugh, and smile.

21. Buddhists are not allowed to desire anything so cannot play sports or achieve anything either.

Main article: Archery & kyudo
Main article: The Zen of Golf

Buddhists play sports and some do very well at it. Tiger Woods is a champion golfer. Buddhist athletes do very well at archery and other sports too. Phil Jackson has won more championships in basketball than anyone else, as a player and coach (combined). Jackie Chan, Steven Seagal, Goldie Hawn and numerous others have made a success at acting. Steve Jobs is the CEO of Apple, Inc. Steve Wynn is the highly successful casino mogul in Las Vegas. Ellison Onizuka was a NASA astronaut. Several Nobel Prize winners have been Buddhist, winning awards in the sciences, medicine, literature, and peace. The Pali term chandha refers to intention, will, and zeal and is used for good and wholesome desires. Not all desires are bad or not allowed. See also Unnabha Paradox and Bhikkhuni Sutta where Buddha's attendant Ananda explains that desire/conceit is used to end all desires and conceit, that one cannot make progress without some desire and conceit.

22. Meditation techniques all advocate repressing and denial of expressing so-called baser emotions and this leads to poor mental health and worse.

Main article: Meditation

It is not a denial, it is just not encouraged. Mindfulness meditation and other Buddhist meditations involve staying in the present and observing whatever comes up; be it good or bad. It is a misconception to say that Buddhist meditations seek to "repress" such feelings. It is more of just staying in the present and seeing what comes up, not repressing anything. There have been some Buddhist teachers who have said that you have never really had a good meditation until you have one that ends in crying. So it can come up in Buddhist meditation, it is just not encouraged.

In Emotional Intelligence, Dr. Daniel Goleman wrote that those who "get it off their chest" can enter a “flooding” state, where there is an overwhelming amount of anger with adrenaline, where no rational decisions can be made in this state and it needs a long recovery time before settling down.

See also